We hear everyday that ' Justice delayed is Justice denied '. Today we have seen a great example of this quote when Supreme Court ...

For the first time in the history of Pakistan, a serving Chief Justice of Apex court is addressing the Senate today. Chief Justice Mr. Ju...

Solicitors told how to draw up Sharia-style wills penalizing widows and non-believers. Islamic law is to be effectively enshrined in t...

When Supreme Court India sentenced a dead man to jail.

We hear everyday that 'Justice delayed is Justice denied'. Today we have seen a great example of this quote when Supreme Court India sentenced a dead man to jail. The Supreme Court India found on Monday that it had sentenced a man to seven years imprisonment finding him guilty of rape charges nearly three years after he had died.

In most of the religions; Dead are believed to face trial for their deeds in the court of God. But the story of this dead man is utterly different where the apex of India found a fault in its decision after seven months of adjudging the man guilty and sentenced him to imprisonment, but yesterday the honorable court has withdrew its judgment against the dead man. It was informed that that the man had died in 2012, three years before he was convicted and sentenced by the SC on April 10, 2015. It is said by Mahatma Gandhi that You must be the change you wish to see in the world but the theme of legal system is going in some other direction.

The police reached the convict's village to arrest him and take him to jail following the SC judgment. But they found that he had already died and no earthly law could now punish him. Ironically, the convict was allegedly killed by his own brother three years back. The police in its report to the Chhattisgarh High Court attached the death certificate and a copy of the murder FIR lodged by his wife.

Taking into account the fact that the person sentenced to undergo imprisonment was no more, the HC sent a report to the SC informing it that the person had died during the pendency of the appeal. After perusing the report, a bench of Justices P C Ghose and R K Agrawal abated the proceedings against him.

The deaf and dumb man was accused of raping a minor girl in 2006. He was acquitted by the trial court as well as the HC, both giving him benefit of doubt as no test identification parade (TIP) was conducted by police for the victim to identify the culprit. Nether court had found substantial evidence against him.

The minor girl approached the apex court in 2009 through her legal guardian challenging the HC order upholding the trial court's decision to acquit him. The SC entertained her plea and issued notice to the accused.

Repeated notices from the SC did not evoke response from the accused. The SC decided to proceed ex-parte and went ahead with the hearing of the girl's appeal by appointing advocate Vanshaja Shukla as amicus curiae to argue on behalf of the accused.

After hearing the state government counsel Shashi Juneja, the amicus and the victim's counsel, the SC on April 10 convicted him and awarded a sentence of seven years in jail. It directed the state authorities to take him in custody forthwith to undergo the sentence.

While reversing the concurrent findings of the trial court and the HC, the SC had ruled TIP was not cardinal to gathering of evidence but a prudent step. The SC held that since the victim identified the accused in court, he could not be acquitted for want of police conducting the TIP. The SC had said that victim's testimony could not be discarded and the trial court as well as HC had erred in acquitting him.

"The clothes worn by the offender were identified by her when called upon to do so. In the circumstances there was nothing wrong or exceptional in identification by her of the accused in court. We find her testimony completely trustworthy and reliable," the court had said.

"No other view was possible and the case therefore warrants interference by this Court. We accordingly allow the appeal and convict him for having committed the offence under Section 376(1) IPC and sentence him to undergo imprisonment for seven years and also impose a fine of Rs.5,000," it had said.
First Time in History, Top Judge addresses senate.

For the first time in the history of Pakistan, a serving Chief Justice of Apex court is addressing the Senate today. Chief Justice Mr. Justice Anwar Zaheer Jamali has addressed senate on Tuesday, 3rd of November, 2015. Chief Justice Anwar Zaheer Jamali  is the 24th Chief Justice of Pakistan and he will be the first judge till yet of the superior judiciary who is going to address the Senate Committee to give recommendations to the government on speedy justice in Pakistan. For this, the upper house will be transforming itself into a committee of the whole house.

According to sources, This was announced by Senate Chairman Raza Rabbani during a Senate meeting on Monday, that Chief Justice Anwar Zaheer Jamali had accepted an invitation to visit and would present his views on judicial reforms. Rabbani added that he had been invited by Supreme Court judges earlier to speak at a ceremony and had extended an invitation to the chief justice as part of his initiative of intra-institutional dialogue.  Asking the members to make sure they are present when the chief justice visits. Earlier, Mr Rabbani said: “The chief justice will present his views before a committee of the whole house at 3:30pm on Tuesday when it will meet to discuss measures to provide inexpensive and speedy justice to people of Pakistan.”


This address was in the context of one meeting of senate of 18 May in which Senators had expressed dissatisfaction over the country’s judicial system and decided to form a committee of the whole house to suggest reforms that will ensure people have access to inexpensive and speedy justice.

Barrister Saif of MQM said, It is a historic moment that CJ is addressing the committee. The development is positive and will enhance interaction between institutions. The initiative is significant with regard to speedy and inexpensive justice, he added. The committee was constituted on a motion moved by Leader of the House in the Senate. Followed by the keynote address of CJP, leader of the house and leader of the opposition would give separate lectures. Senate, some months back amended its rules to hear voice from outside the house on matters of national interest.

Later on, Chief Justice of Pakistan addresses the senate in which he has reminded senators of their constitutional duties during his maiden address in the Upper House of Parliament on Tuesday.


“The lawmakers elected by people should work towards bridging the gap between state institutions and the general populace,” Jamali told the senators, adding that the Constitution of Pakistan gives equal rights to all citizens of the state and the dream of a welfare state with a strong government will only come true if legislators also respect the law they expect the public to obey.

The Chief Justice said the process of supremacy of law plays a crucial role in keeping the state alive. “We all are followers of the law and not of an individual”. CJP said while addressing the Senate that this visit is one step of a series to strengthen the importance of institutions. He said he has presented recommendation for cheap and quick justice because the constitution has explained the state’s bounds and limits in details and the constitutional structure dictates transfer of authority to the public.

“The preamble of the Constitution clearly states that sovereignty belongs to Almighty Allah alone, and the political power rests with the people of Pakistan who elect you to exercise it on their behalf, which is a sacred trust,” the CJP reminded the House.

Jamali maintained that Law and Justice Commission has already presented its recommendations in the light of the Article 37 of the Constitution and this speech is just a continuation of efforts of the commission for the promotion of social justice, a constitutional responsibility.

“We all agree on constitution and upholding the laws of land and in some departments, we have more laws than we need but the real test lies in their implementation which sadly, is absent in many departments,” said the CJP.

Laws, no matter how well prepared, are of no use when their implementation is neglected. The chief justice maintained that we have no mechanism to determine the quality of our performance other than people’s complaints. In case of unrest among public and lack of responsibility among lawmakers, it becomes the responsibility of judiciary to intervene and play its role in administrative reforms, he added.

He said in his address that policies of the state must be in line with the wishes of the people, adding that they have to ensure the supremacy of the law and that the government must provide a conducive environment for it.“The supremacy of law is an inevitable need because the country’s future depends on it”, he added. He said all factions of society must have access to the law. “We all are on same page on supremacy of the law”, he said.Justice Jamali said there is no system to measure the performance and comments, adding that the supervision to check the quality of the justice delivered is also lacking.
Islamic law is adopted by British legal chiefs.

Solicitors told how to draw up Sharia-style wills penalizing widows and non-believers. Islamic law is to be effectively enshrined in the British legal system for the first time under guidelines for solicitors on drawing up “Sharia compliant” wills. Under ground-breaking guidance, produced by The Law Society, High Street solicitors will be able to write Islamic wills that deny women an equal share of inheritances and exclude unbelievers altogether.

As mentioned in The Telegraph UK; The documents, which would be recognized by Britain’s courts, will also prevent children born out of wedlock – and even those who have been adopted – from being counted as legitimate heirs. Anyone married in a church, or in a civil ceremony, could be excluded from succession under Sharia principles, which recognize only Muslim weddings for inheritance purposes. Nicholas Fluck, president of The Law Society, said the guidance would promote “good practice” in applying Islamic principles in the British legal system.

Some lawyers, however, described the guidance as “astonishing”, while campaigners warned it represented a major step on the road to a “parallel legal system” for Britain’s Muslim communities.
Baroness Cox, a cross-bench peer leading a Parliamentary campaign to protect women from religiously sanctioned discrimination, including from unofficial Sharia courts in Britain, said it was a “deeply disturbing” development and pledged to raise it with ministers.

“This violates everything that we stand for,” she said. “It would make the Suffragettes turn in their graves.”
The guidance, quietly published this month and distributed to solicitors in England and Wales, details how wills should be drafted to fit Islamic traditions while being valid under British law. It suggests deleting or amending standard legal terms and even words such as “children” to ensure that those deemed “illegitimate” are denied any claim over the inheritance.

It recommends that some wills include a declaration of faith in Allah which would be drafted at a local mosque, and hands responsibility for drawing up some papers to Sharia courts. The guidance goes on to suggest that Sharia principles could potentially overrule British practices in some disputes, giving examples of areas that would need to be tested in English courts.

Currently, Sharia principles are not formally addressed by or included in Britain’s laws.
However, a network of Sharia courts has grown up in Islamic communities to deal with disputes between Muslim families.

A few are officially recognised tribunals, operating under the Arbitration Act. They have powers to set contracts between parties, mainly in commercial disputes, but also to deal with issues such as domestic violence, family disputes and inheritance battles. But many more unofficial Sharia courts are also in operation.

Parliament has been told of a significant network of more informal Sharia tribunals and “councils”, often based in mosques, dealing with religious divorces and even child custody matters in line with religious teaching.

They offer “mediation” rather than adjudication, although some hearings are laid out like courts with religious scholars or legal experts sitting in a manner more akin to judges than counsellors.

One study estimated that there were now around 85 Sharia bodies operating in Britain. But the new Law Society guidance represents the first time that an official legal body has recognised the legitimacy of some Sharia principles.

It opens the way for non-Muslim lawyers in High Street firms to offer Sharia will drafting services. The document sets out crucial differences between Sharia inheritance laws and Western traditions.

It explains how, in Islamic custom, inheritances are divided among a set list of heirs determined by ties of kinship rather than named individuals. It acknowledges the possibility of people having multiple marriages.
“The male heirs in most cases receive double the amount inherited by a female heir of the same class,” the guidance says. “Non-Muslims may not inherit at all, and only Muslim marriages are recognised.

Similarly, a divorced spouse is no longer a Sharia heir, as the entitlement depends on a valid Muslim marriage existing at the date of death. This means you should amend or delete some standard will clauses.”
It advises lawyers to draft special exclusions from the Wills Act 1837, which allows gifts to pass to the children of an heir who has died, because this is not recognised in Islamic law.

Keith Porteous Wood, executive director of the National Secular Society, said: “This guidance marks a further stage in the British legal establishment’s undermining of democratically determined human rights-compliant law in favour of religious law from another era and another culture. British equality law is more comprehensive in scope and remedies than any elsewhere in the world. Instead of protecting it, The Law Society seems determined to sacrifice the progress made in the last 500 years.”

Lady Cox said: “Everyone has freedom to make their own will and everyone has freedom to let those wills reflect their religious beliefs. But to have an organisation such as The Law Society seeming to promote or encourage a policy which is inherently gender discriminatory in a way which will have very serious implications for women and possibly for children is a matter of deep concern.”